Discussion or argument? #MondayMusings

It is high time we understand that an argument is not a quarrel or a temper tantrum or generating random noise!

It has a narrative logic to it and is a form of conversation where a person/s stacks a set of instances to prove a point. The fun is in the transparency of this stacking, the stacking of these instances and proving that point so that anybody who uses this same stack can take stand, similar, different or mixed when it is opened up for discussion to foster a participation. The multiple points of view and the discussion that follows gives us/me a kind of a cerebral orgasm, a befitting finale to a round of conversations. visual-metaphors-argument

http://sachachua.com/blog/2012/04/visual-metaphors-argument/

To the uninitiated, this is a fight or an ego clash because there is absolutely no culture of arguing out in many homes, schools and other work places. It is almost always discouraged. However, argument is an art that needs to be taught. It has to be differentiated from say, a street rabble. It may be a fight of ideas from different perspectives on an ideological plane. What it does is, it helps us to think through, find proof, unlearn, then relearn, and accept.  A certain amount of unlearning is necessary to live and then look out for the alternatives to the official dominant histories to get the whole picture so that we can argue it out if needed be to understand a given situation better 🙂 At the end of the day, we are richer in thought 🙂

visual-metaphors-balance1
It is always fun to sit as a group and have a conversation. It could be about anything, it could be about different view points. We would talk about it, dominate a particular strand of thought, manipulate others into believing the bluff, survive (in the Darwinian sense)… act as a mediator, send the line of thought in an absolutely different direction, turn something on its head, bring in n number of examples to prove a point, rehearse another line of thought, bring another set of examples, take refuge in another’s view point, take that into our stride and prove our point again.. there are strategies, many ways, and a respect for each other. Nevertheless, at the end of those many hours, we are still friends but on a high…

To an onlooker, it may look like a fight of words in the brewing, ready to erupt or that which has already erupted. They stand by, ready to dive in, to save the situation in case of an emergency. With voices raised, all at a time, a few towering over the rest, the rest restless to dive in to make a point, add to it the many gesticulations… somebody stands up with a restlessness, somebody tapping their feet in anticipation, another clawing their fingers into their skin … the scene is deceiving…

A Vibrant Palette

I’ve often seen that while people feign they’re up for some healthy discussion regarding any matter, soon the whole exercise becomes futile by their sheer belligerence and unpreparedness to accept a point of view that doesn’t agree with theirs.

In no time, to keep up our side of the deal, we end up justifying ourselves to them when they aren’t willing to even hear us out. Aggression, a high pitched tone or not giving the other person a chance to speak doesn’t make anyone right. Does it?

I find this whole thing very draining. May be that’s why I never scored well in GDs too. I refused to scream and be dragged into ugly arguments by my team members when the topic was something else to begin with. For the same reason I’ve tried to keep my blog free of any ‘volatile’ stuff too.

To get answers and solutions we…

View original post 32 more words

Advertisements

Published by

pins & ashes

An Aquarius Woman

17 thoughts on “Discussion or argument? #MondayMusings”

  1. Now that’s something interesting you wrote. Well crafted ! At times while discussing ego stands by to further make it an argument of honor and pride even forgetting a topic/ subject entirely eg : The news channels so called discussions.

    Like

        1. little information is always dangerous, so is being a big fish in a small pool. both are dangerous!

          Everybody has something to offer for us to learn on a daily minute basis starting with a spelling. so why shut out that opportunity at all and be at some ego level!

          Liked by 1 person

          1. Oh well…. There were other reasons for the name change….
            But I do offer astrology services…. If you ever need….
            That’s a very nice name, though the current one is more beautiful…
            BTW what’s the story behind your blog name…

            Like

Your turn..

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s